When Katherine Carrane returned home to her bedroom from the
hospital, the toe shoes hanging in her room no longer looked like the
next step in her dream to become a ballerina. Instead, the shoes
reminded her of a recent and succinct split: her life before and after the
accident.
Just a few months earlier, Carrane had stood waiting for the bus to
arrive on a busy corner in suburban Philadelphia. She had lingered
longer than usual that morning at home, hugging her mother and
sleepily protesting her insistence that she attend seventh grade. It was
September, the beginning of a difficult transition to junior high. She
dragged her feet to the bus stop and chatted with other girls as they
waited. It had rained that night, but the sky had just cleared in the early
morning. Carrane stood at the outmost stretch of the circle, her back to
the road.
Behind her, the light turned yellow. A driver hesitated, deciding whether
to try and make the light, then braked. The streets were still wet. He spun
through the light, through the intersection, and into the group of
schoolgirls. Carrane took the brunt of the damage, hit twice by the
spinning car. She can still hear the sound of the impact: a loud, sharp
sound, like the strike of a bowling ball against pins.
There were screams, some shouts warning her not to get up. "My body
felt heavy and hot. I thought, something bad's happened. It felt like jelly.
Like I was jelly. And I thought, oh, this isn't good."
The impact had broken her pelvis and shattered her legs. A friend of
hers ran home to call the police and an ambulance. "I don't remember
being put in the ambulance, but I remember the ride. We were going
down the street toward Bryn Mawr Hospital and the way we were going
was away from my house. And I thought, I want to be going that way. I
want to go home." Carrane wouldn't return home for months. It would be
a fight to save her legs. After multiple surgeries, the doctor scheduled an
amputation for her right leg. The day of the surgery, he detected a
heartbeat in the leg and called it off.
Throughout this, the driver of the car, Juan (Carrane doesn't know his
last name), came to the hospital daily to check on her, though she never
met him. "I was so sick; he would just sit outside my room. But I've
thought about him. I think about what he's had to live with, and the
trauma that he's endured, and I want him to know, accidents happen. I'm
not angry with him. It was a mistake. But my parents-my father in
particular-was enraged. He said, you can't come anymore. You can't be
here." Her father lost a leg in an accident when he was twelve.
Over the next decade, Carrane learned to walk again. The damage left
its mark on her body. Her pelvis healed incorrectly, her legs are slightly
different lengths and severely scarred, and she has no motion in her
right ankle. As a young adult, she was self-conscious about her legs,
covering them up and even going so far as to wear heavy, water-logged
sweatpants when swimming.
"I was so naive," she recalls. "I had one doctor who told me, you know
what, when you get older, this will all be fixed up. And I thought, literally,
when I get older, they're going to fix this and it won't look the same.
When I think about it now, I think, how did my brain let me think that? But
it was a way to wrap my mind around it all."
She went in college to see a plastic surgeon for a consultation, thinking
it was time to "fix it all up." Wanting to be tough, she went by herself
while her parents waited. "[The doctor] said, 'You've had your surgery.
They did a great job.' And I thought, 'Great? This doesn't look great, what
are you talking about? I want my regular old legs back.' I remember
being so devastated. It was the first time anyone had sat me down and
said, look, you're going to have to live with this for the rest of your life. So
get used to it."
But it wasn't as easy as that. Carrane had never spoken professionally
to anyone about the accident. It wasn't until she attended graduate
school at the University of Chicago that she sought out a
psychotherapist. "I remember my therapist introducing me to the idea of
choice to me, saying, you have the choice not to hide. It might be an
uncomfortable situation, and you don't have to be all out with it either,
but you have the choice."
These words prompted Carrane to take the first step toward becoming
comfortable with the damage left by the accident-a process that would
take years. She wore shorts to school. People looked, she said, but no
one stared or really reacted. She decided to stop covering up-a decision
later reinforced when raising two girls, Hope and Maddy, now 9 and 6. "I
don't really think I could fully say, 'No big thing,' until I had daughters.
And then I really thought, I want them to really know that it doesn't matter
what's on the outside of anybody. That what's important is what's on the
inside. I didn't want them to see me struggling, and I didn't want to
struggle anymore." She knew she couldn't teach them to think healthily
about their bodies while still being ashamed of hers. Now, when asked
about her legs, she just laughs and says, "They're just for getting me
around."
Carrane's tirelessness and genuine smile carries over to her daughters,
who look to their mother with adoration. It's clear they not only think their
mother is no different from anyone else, but better than everyone else.
They gather around her, wiggling and vying for her attention. Once a
week, the three of them meet up for "The Sisterhood" to talk about girl
things. Carrane aims to make sure her daughters are comfortable
talking about everything with her and grow up with good attitudes about
being girls.
Competing in triathlons also helped Carrane transition into total comfort
in her body. Over the past four years, Carrane has completed six
triathlons, with four more coming up this summer. Her passion for tri's
was born spontaneously on the stoop of her neighbor's house, when
they hatched a plan to train and complete their first triathlon together. "I
don't know what came over me. Maybe I was turning 40, that milestone
birthday, but I said, yeah, I'll do that with you." Her neighbor didn't know
about Carrane's accident. They started meeting early in the morning,
training little by little for the big day. Carrane bikes and swims, but has to
walk the run portion. "We had really little clue what we were getting
ourselves into.
"It was a week before the Glenview triathlon, and [my neighbor's
husband] said you know, you guys, you have to do two laps on the bike.
Not just one. Because we were just practicing doing one at the course-
we thought, that's a piece of cake. We can totally do this. And then we
thought, 'Oh, two? That's going to be a little harder.'" She lets out a
raucous laugh. "And then I just fell in love with it. I loved the challenge,
and I loved that it was something I didn't even imagine doing, and then I
did it. I finished the very last. I was the last person to finish the race. But I
finished it. Now I have to figure out how to train and do this right, I
thought."
Crossing the finish line that first time was both emotionally and
physically draining, Carrane says. She hadn't been prepared for the
level of competition she encountered at the race. "I kept thinking it was
an individual thing, which is what initially attracted me to it. I just thought,
I'll just do my own thing. But I got there and I saw these people with their
game faces on, very buff, very serious about it. And they're flying by me
on the bike and they're flying past me in the pool. So that side-swiped
me a little bit."
But Carrane decided to use that competitiveness to her advantage, as a
tool to urge her on when she wanted to slow down or quit. "When I'm
thinking, I'm so tired, I can't lift my arm one more inch, [the competition
aspect] tells me, keep going, keep going, you can do it." After her first tri,
she decided to get serious. She joined a spin class and enrolled in a
training group, Together We Tri, run by Kate Schnatterbeck in Glenview.
Carrane was nervous about training with the group, but found a
supportive team that would motivate her to do her best. "I'm always the
last to finish. But it never crossed any of their minds that I couldn't do it. I
was prepared for a barrage of questions, but no. No one batted an eye.
Now I can't imagine doing this without the group. It's just so meaningful,
and the people are all so lovely, and the support, and the good energy
of it."
Carrane cries at every finish line, where her daughters meet her after
every race. "In my brain, I can be Lance Armstrong on the bike, or
Amanda Beard in the water, or Michael Johnson when I'm running. But I
know I'll never be like that. And that's okay." That's what she wants to
show her daughters. And she has.
Emily Withrow is a freelance writer and photographer based in
Chicago. Her work has appeared in the Onion A.V. Club and the
Daily Herald's Beep. Reach her at emilywithrow@gmail.com.